Skip to content

Audit Full Support Ticket Volume Against Empathy and Resolution Rubrics

Move past random 2% manual ticket sampling—auditing every closed interaction for policy accuracy, compliance disclosures, completeness, and agent coaching wins.

Copy the prompt and paste it into the AI assistant you already use.

Four steps to roll out fair 100% support QA auditing

  1. 01

    Replace subjective vibe scores with observable behaviors

    Grade specific actions—confirmed root cause, matched KB policy, answered all sub-questions, set clear next timeline—rather than vague 'warmth'.

  2. 02

    Calibrate AI scores against 40 manager-graded tickets first

    Compare automated rubric grades against two human QA leads on 40 transcripts, tuning criteria until agreement exceeds 85%.

  3. 03

    Focus manager review time on the bottom 3% and top 3%

    Instead of reading random routine password resets, review flagged policy mistakes for remediation and celebrate exceptional saves in team huddles.

  4. 04

    Give agents a 1-click 'Dispute QA Score' button

    Allow agents to flag edge cases where an offline call or approved manager override explained an apparent rubric deviation.

Common questions

Why does random 2% manual ticket sampling fail both customers and support agents?

Random samples mostly pull easy routine tickets—missing rare high-risk compliance mistakes while judging an agent's entire month on five lucky or unlucky draws.

Should automated AI QA scores directly determine agent bonuses on Day 1?

No—use automated QA purely for coaching prioritization and process discovery during the first two quarters, keeping compensation decisions human-verified.

Can automated QA grade both human agents and our AI chatbot on the exact same rubric?

Yes—scoring bot conversations alongside human tickets on resolution completeness and policy accuracy reveals immediately where bot guardrails need tightening.

Learn more

Related guides and background articles for this task